3:47pm

Wed March 14, 2012
Fine Art

800-Year-Old Frescoes Leave Texas For Cyprus

Originally published on Wed May 23, 2012 10:57 am

A set of 13th-century Byzantine frescoes — plundered after Turkey invaded Cyprus and on display in Houston for the last 15 years — is headed home at last. It's the closing chapter in what turns out to be a remarkable odyssey.

It all started in the summer of 1974, when the Turkish army invaded Cyprus and nearly 200,000 Greek Cypriots became refugees fleeing south.

"And so all the churches and homes and art was left behind," says Josef Helfenstein, director of the Menil Collection in Houston. "And after years, some of these churches began to be looted."

Hundreds of them, in fact, including a tiny 13th-century limestone chapel outside the small Cypriot town of Lysi. It took several years before somebody noticed the two incredible 800-year-old frescoes inside the Greek Orthodox sanctuary, but eventually somebody figured it out. Thieves took a chainsaw and brutally hacked the frescoes out of the dome and apse — in 38 pieces.

"The only way to get them out of there was to cut them into pieces," Helfenstein says. "And they were shipped to Germany."

In Munich, a Turkish dealer offered them to Dominique de Menil, a noted collector and art patron. He claimed they'd been found in a private home in Anatolia, Turkey. Menil, standing in a warehouse in front of a set of chopped-up 13th-century frescoes, was pretty sure she knew better.

"That was a lie," Helfenstein says. "And so Mrs. de Menil was very quickly suspicious — and she had very good advisers. She had a world-class specialist in Byzantine art."

De Menil told the Turkish dealer she wanted to take pictures of the frescoes to look at while she pondered her decision to buy. But that was a trick; instead her researchers painstakingly tracked the frescoes back to Cyprus. It took more than a year.

De Menil contacted the archbishop responsible for the looted chapel, offering to ransom the frescoes from the so-called "owners" and then restore them — at a cost of more than $1 million. In return, she wanted to display them in Houston for a while before repatriating them.

The deal she struck, Helfenstein says, means "we are the only place west of Cyprus to have frescoes of that significance on display."

'Heartbreaking' Losses, But One Major Step In The Right Direction

For the last 15 years, the frescoes have been on display in Houston, in a $4 million chapel that was designed and built especially for them on the Menil Collection campus. Hundreds of thousands of visitors have worshiped there, listened to concerts and education programs, or simply sat in quiet appreciation under their gaze.

But now it's time for the frescoes to go home, and the Rev. Demosthenis Demosthenous has traveled from Cyprus to accompany them. He says what's been stolen from Greek Orthodox churches is heartbreaking.

"Twenty-three thousand icons dated from the 12th to the 20th century," he says. "Most were paintings, even mosaics. They are lost — and they are found all over the world."

Demosthenous says what Dominique de Menil did stands as an example to the collecting world. Instead of quietly purchasing the frescoes for her museum — in the guise of "rescuing them for mankind" — and then defending her acquisition against subsequent ownership claims, she negotiated a historic agreement with the Church of Cyprus. The black-robed priest beams as he talks, his smile lighting up his bearded face. It's his first time to America.

"I am really very, very, very happy to be here in America," he says. "I always remember Neil Armstrong and Martin Luther King." And he remembers Dominique de Menil, who died in 1997. It's a short but strong list of favorite Americans.

In these last few weeks of the frescoes' Houston life, visitors flocked to the Byzantine Fresco Chapel to see them before they left forever. The artwork will not go back to the small chapel outside Lysi where they'd lived for the last 800 years — it's still inside Turkish-occupied Cyprus.

But they will be displayed about 40 miles away, in the archbishop's museum. There, they'll join other plundered artwork that's been rescued from around the world, but can't make it all the way home.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

Finally this hour, a journey that began nearly 40 years ago is coming to an end. A set of 13th century frescoes were plundered from a church in Cyprus. They ended up in a museum in Houston and now they're headed home.

NPR's Wade Goodwyn tells us about the frescoes' odyssey.

WADE GOODWYN, BYLINE: It all started in the summer of 1974, when the Turkish Army invaded Cyprus and nearly 200,000 Greek Cypriats became refugees fleeing south.

JOSEF HELFENSTEIN: And so all the churches and, you know, homes and art was left behind and, after years, some of these churches started to be looted and that happened to this church.

GOODWYN: Josef Helfenstein is the director of the Menil Collection in Houston. Helfenstein says hundreds of Greek Orthodox churches were abandoned, including a tiny limestone 13th century chapel outside the small town of Lysi. It took several years before somebody noticed the two incredible 800-year-old frescoes inside, but somebody eventually figured it out. They took a chainsaw and brutally hacked them out of the dome in 38 pieces.

HELFENSTEIN: The only way to get them out of there was to cut them in pieces and then they were shipped to Germany, were offered to Mrs. De Menil, were presented as found frescoes from Anatolia in eastern Turkey.

GOODWYN: The dome fresco portrays Christ in heaven surrounded by 12 angels, each robed in a different color. The archangels Michael and Gabriel flank the Virgin Mary and John the Baptist as a medallion illustrates the throne that's been prepared for the Lord.

Helfenstein says Dominique de Menil, standing in a Munich warehouse in front of chopped up 13th century frescoes, knew these were not works of art that had just been miraculously discovered in some Turkish home.

HELFENSTEIN: That was a lie and so, Mrs. De Menil was, of course, very quickly suspicious and she had very good advisors. She had a world class specialist of Byzantine art.

GOODWYN: De Menil told the Turkish dealer she wanted to take pictures of the frescoes to look at while she pondered her decision to buy, but that was a trick. Instead, her researchers painstakingly tracked the frescoes back to Cyprus. It took more than a year. De Menil contacted the archbishop and offered to ransom the frescoes from the so-called owners and then restore them at a cost of over a million dollars. In return, she wanted to display them in Houston before returning them.

HELFENSTEIN: What it means is that we are the only place west of Cyprus to have frescoes of that significance.

GOODWYN: The last 15 years, the frescoes have been on display in Houston at a $4 million chapel that was designed and built especially for them on the Menil museum campus. Hundreds of thousands of visitors have worshipped there, listened to music concerts and education programs or simply sat in quiet appreciation under their 13th century gaze.

But now, it's time for the frescoes to go. Reverend Demosthenis Demosthenous has traveled from Cyprus to accompany them home. He says what's been stolen from Greek Orthodox churches is heartbreaking.

REVEREND DEMOSTHENIS DEMOSTHENOUS: Twenty-three thousand icons dated from 12th to 20th century, most oil paintings, even mosaics, they are lost and they are found all over the world.

GOODWYN: Reverend Demosthenous says what Dominique de Menil did shines as an example to the collecting world. Instead of quietly purchasing the frescoes for her museum in the guise of rescuing them for mankind and then defending her acquisition against all subsequent ownership claims, she negotiated an historic agreement with the Church of Cyprus.

The black-robed priest beams as he talks, smiles lighting up his bearded face. It's his first time to America.

DEMOSTHENOUS: I really - I am really, really, really happy to be here in America. I always remember Neil Armstrong and Martin Luther King.

GOODWYN: And Dominique de Menil, who died in 1997. It's a short, but strong list of favorite Americans. The Byzantine frescoes arrive in Cyprus Friday.

Wade Goodwyn, NPR News, Dallas. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.