Afghan Women Fear Backsliding On Key Gains

Aug 27, 2012
Originally published on August 27, 2012 6:23 pm

The gains by Afghan women are seen as one of the country's most important achievements over the past decade. But as the international community draws down its military and aid presence, those hard-won gains are at risk of being lost, according to activists.

Women are still being beaten, raped and forced into early marriage at alarming rates. And women's advocacy groups say they are already seeing signs of backsliding by the government when it comes to protecting women, and fear this could accelerate in the coming years.

A 16-Year-Old's Struggle

Women for Afghan Women, which runs shelters and advocacy programs, has helped thousands of victims of violence and abuse over the past decade. One of its current cases involves a 16-year-old girl they call Peri.

Peri looks short for her age. She has a pretty face with sad, brown eyes.

Speaking in a detached manner, Peri says when she was 3, her father was accused of killing a member of another family in her village. In a traditional compensation, Peri was given to the family of the victim. It's a process called baad. It's illegal but very common.

Her story gets worse. She says that when she was 10, she was raped by a man in that family, and afterward she was forced to marry a boy in the same family who was also around 10. One day when she was 14, she says, she was drugged and when she came to, she was told she had been divorced. She never saw her husband again.

A year later, Peri was forced to become the second wife of another man who regularly abused her. The other wife threatened Peri and ultimately forced her to leave the house. Peri then tried to kill herself in the street. A man stopped her and brought her to the police, who took her to a shelter.

Fighting Abuse With Lawyers

With the help of Women for Afghan Women, a case has been filed against Peri's husband and brother-in-law. They are being charged with rape, forced marriage and abuse.

But the prospects for justice in this case are not good, says Huma Safi, the program manager for Women for Afghan Women, which is based in New York.

"The most corrupt system in our country is the system of justice," Safi says. "We have good laws. They are very good ... written in the documents, but they are not good in the implementation."

In another case, a woman was raped by an Afghan policeman, Safi says. A court sentenced him to seven years in jail. But the appeals court changed the charge from rape to adultery, freed the officer and sent the woman to jail for three years.

"It's very difficult for a woman who is uneducated, staying in a very remote area of the country, to have proof," Safi says. She says cases are often dismissed or lost because women can't provide evidence of the crimes against them.

Many of these cases are handled through tribal or informal justice systems that are often heavily slanted against women. But through persistence, Safi says, some measure of justice is achieved. Usually, it comes down to the individual judge making the decision.

Advocates Living Under Threat

She says there are a few sympathetic judges, lawyers and advocates. However, they can face constant threats, like Soraya Paksat, who works for a women's rights organization in the western city of Herat.

The Voice of Afghan Women was founded secretly during the years that the Taliban ruled, from 1996 to 2001. Recently, the women's group intervened in a case where an Afghan local policeman and two others kidnapped and raped a 17-year-old girl. The group pushed for prosecution, and as a result, the men received long prison sentences. Now, the judges and advocates like Paksat are receiving death threats.

"What I received from that threat was three bullets in one envelope [sent] to my home — just a message," says Maria Bashir.

Bashir, the prosecutor general in Herat, is the only female prosecutor general in the country. In one instance, her house was set on fire. Another time, her house was bombed. She continues to receive frequent threats.

"My children can't go outside the house, and I always have to be escorted by security personnel," Bashir says.

Bashir tries to focus on positives. She says that more and more women are becoming aware of their rights and seeking justice. However, she's also seeing men become more angry and abusive toward women who try to assert their rights.

Keeping Women's Rights On The Table

Bashir is concerned that when foreign forces leave, women will lose protection. Plus, she and others fear that the government is already starting to chip away at women's rights.

"If there is a political solution between Taliban and government and Hizb-i-Islami, there is no doubt that they will not accept the article on women's rights in the constitution," Bashir says.

But Salahuddin Rabbani, who heads the High Peace Council, a group seeking reconciliation in Afghanistan, says there will be no deals to rework the constitution or sacrifice women's rights in exchange for peace with the Taliban.

"This is something that is nonnegotiable," he says.

However, women's advocates say the current government is still backsliding and not enforcing the laws as it was a couple of years ago.

Paksat says women's rights have been treated as a cause, rather than as a pillar of Afghan government and society. That makes women more vulnerable as the international community pulls back.

'Abuses' From Within

In a recent speech, Afghanistan's justice minister called women's shelters dens of prostitution, and declared that girls are ready for marriage by age 12. Safi, in Kabul, says she was shocked to hear such comments from a government minister.

"For me, there is no difference between that Talib who is fighting and a minister who is saying such a thing," she says.

This raises another issue. While there is a constant threat of violence against women from the Taliban or other insurgents, women like Safi say that it's those who are supposed to uphold the law who are often breaking it.

"Day by day, we see the local commanders are very powerful, and most of the abuses come from those people who are working with the government — they're not Taliban," Safi says.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

Women in Afghanistan are generally considered to be better off today than they were during the rule of the Taliban. But activists say there's still a long way to go. Women are still being beaten, raped, and forced into marriage at alarming rates. And women's groups worry that as the international community draws down its military and aid presence, Afghan women will be even more vulnerable.

NPR's Sean Carberry was recently in Kabul and sent this report.

SEAN CARBERRY, BYLINE: Women for Afghan Women is a New York-based organization that runs shelters and advocacy programs in Afghanistan. The group helped thousands of victims of violence and abuse since 2001. One of its current cases involves a 16-year-old girl they call Peri.

PERI: (Foreign language spoken)

CARBERRY: Peri looks short for her age, but has a pretty face with sad brown eyes. Speaking in a detached manner, Peri says that when she was three, her father was accused of killing a member of another family in her village. In a traditional compensation, Peri was given to the family of the victim. It's a process called Baad. It's illegal, but very common.

PERI: (Foreign language spoken)

CARBERRY: Her story gets worse. She says that when she was 10, she was raped by a man in that family, and afterwards she was forced to marry a boy of the same family who was also around 10. One day when she was 14, she says she was drugged and when she came to, she was told she had been divorced. She never saw her husband again.

PERI: (Foreign language spoken)

CARBERRY: A year later, Peri was forced to become the second wife of another man who regularly abused her. The other wife threatened Peri and ultimately forced her to leave the house. Peri then tried to kill herself in the street. A man stopped her and brought her to the police who took her to a shelter.

PERI: (Foreign language spoken)

CARBERRY: With the help of Women for Afghan Women, a case has been filed against Peri's husband and brother-in-law. They are being charged with rape, forced marriage and abuse.

But the prospects for justice in this case are not good, says Huma Safi, the program manager for Women for Afghan Women.

HUMA SAFI: As you know, the most corrupted system in our country is the system of justice. We have good laws. They are very good in written in the documents but they are not good in the implementation.

CARBERRY: Safi relates another case, a woman was raped by an Afghan policeman. The primary court sentenced him to seven years in jail. But the appeals court changed the charge from rape to adultery, freed the officer and sent the woman to jail for three years. Safi says this often happens because women can't provide evidence of the crimes against them.

SAFI: It's very difficult for a woman who is uneducated, staying in a very remote of area of country, to have proof.

CARBERRY: Many of these cases are handled through tribal or informal justice systems that are often heavily slanted against women. But through persistence, Safi says, some measure of justice is achieved.

SAFI: For the cases when we win the case and, you know, the woman gets to the justice, its most on the individual. You know, who is the judge making the decision?

CARBERRY: She says there are a few good judges, lawyers and advocates out there. But those few good people face constant threats. People like Soraya Paksat, who works for a women's rights organization in the western city of Herat. After intervening in a rape case there, she began receiving death threats.

SORAYA PARKSAT: And what I received from that threat was three bullets in one envelope sending to my home, just a message.

CARBERRY: Maria Bashir receives threats on a regular basis. And worse, she's the prosecutor general in Herat. She's the only female prosecutor general in the country. Bashir's had one house set on fire and another bombed.

MARIA BASHIR: (Through translator) My children can't go outside the house. And I always have to be escorted by security personnel.

(Foreign language spoken)

CARBERRY: Bashir tries to focus on positives. She says that more and more women are becoming aware of their rights and seeking justice. But she's also seeing men become more angry and abusive towards women who try to assert their rights. Bashir is concerned that when foreign forces leave, women will lose protection. Plus, she and others fear that the government is already starting to chip away at women's rights.

For example, in a recent speech, Afghanistan's justice minister called women's shelters dens of prostitution, and declared that girls are ready for marriage by age 12.

Huma Safi in Kabul says she was shocked to hear such comments from a government minister.

SAFI: And for me there is no difference between that Talib who is fighting and between a minister who is telling such a thing.

CARBERRY: This raises another issue of great concern. While there's a constant threat of violence against women from the Taliban or other insurgents, women such as Huma Safi say that it's those who are supposed to uphold the law who are now most likely to break it.

SAFI: Day by day, we see the local commanders are very powerful. And most of the abuses come from those people, they are working with the government. They are not Taliban.

CARBERRY: That's just one more reason why there's not a lot of optimism about the future of women's rights in Afghanistan at the moment.

Sean Carberry, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

CORNISH: This is NPR. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.