Caribbean Coral Catch Disease From Sewage

Aug 17, 2011
Originally published on August 17, 2011 9:40 pm

Human beings occasionally get diseases from animals, such as swine flu, rabies and anthrax. A new study finds that humans can also spread disease to wildlife, with grim results. A bacterium from our guts is now rampaging through coral reefs in the Caribbean.

Those reefs were already in slow decline, but they took a huge hit starting in 1996, when a disease called white pox appeared in the Florida Keys.

"Since that time, elkhorn coral — the species it affects — has declined 88 percent in the Florida Keys," says Kathryn Sutherland, a reef ecologist at Rollins College in Florida. "And we've seen similar declines elsewhere in the Caribbean."

The coral is named for its resemblance to elk antlers, and is among the most important reef-building species in the Caribbean. Sutherland and her colleagues soon found a culprit for the die-off — a bacterium called Serratia marcescens. It also happens to cause disease in human beings, notably hospital infections. But the scientists couldn't prove cause and effect.

"In 2002, we could only speculate that human waste was the source of the pathogen because the pathogen is also found in the guts of other animals," such as deer, Sutherland says.

So she and some colleagues exposed the coral in the laboratory to bacteria extracted from sewage. As they report in the journal PLoS ONE, the coral got the pox within days.

"That gave us definitive evidence that white pox disease is caused by a pathogen found in human sewage."

An 'Evolutionary Triple Jump'

Traditionally, we think of diseases moving from animals to us, but "this is almost a man-bites-dog story," says James Porter at the University of Georgia, a co-author of the study.

"This is a very rare and unusual evolutionary triple jump," Porter says. The bacterium "went from humans to the lower invertebrates — coral. It went from the terrestrial environment to the marine environment. And then it went from the anaerobic [low oxygen] conditions of our stomach to the fully oxygenated conditions on the reef."

Porter says they are still trying to explain exactly how the bacterium makes coral sick, and why white pox appeared so suddenly and viciously. The good news is those answers aren't needed to protect coral. You can just keep the germ away. And, happily, that's been happening along the Florida Keys.

Jay Gewin, utilities manager in the city of Key West, says residents there voted to upgrade their leaky sewer system. It was not done to save coral per se, but to get rid of health warnings that were keeping the tourists away.

"In the early 2000s when this was such a problem, every single beach in the city of Key West would have an advisory," Gewin says.

Those health warnings on the beach are now rare, thanks to a sophisticated new wastewater system that cost the city more than $70 million.

"The wastewater is treated to the highest level in the state of Florida, and then it goes into a deep injection well, where the treated final water product is sent thousands of feet down into the ground," Gewin says.

Eventually it may seep back up into the ocean, but he says by then it's clean. The biologists say that since the new system was installed, there haven't been any further die-offs of elkhorn coral around Key West. Other towns along the Keys are now in the process of cleaning up their act, too.

"But this is a problem Caribbean-wide," Sutherland says, "and there's a widespread lack of wastewater treatment in the wider Caribbean region."

And that's bad news for the elkhorn coral. Due largely to the disease spreading from humans, it's been tagged as vulnerable on the endangered species list.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, Host:

Human beings occasionally get diseases from animals - think of swine flu, rabies, anthrax. And while it's rare, it turns out humans can also spread disease to wildlife, with grim results. NPR's Richard Harris reports on a study about a disease that is killing coral.

RICHARD HARRIS: Coral reefs throughout the Caribbean have been suffering sharp declines in recent years and one of the most devastating causes is a disease called white pox.

KATHRYN SUTHERLAND: White pox disease was first described in the Florida Keys in 1996.

HARRIS: Kathryn Sutherland is a coral reef ecologist at Rollins College in Florida.

SUTHERLAND: And since that time, elkhorn coral, the species that it affects, has declined on average of 88 percent in the Florida Keys and we are seeing similar declines elsewhere in the Caribbean.

HARRIS: Sutherland and her colleagues soon found a culprit for the die-off, a bacterium called Serratia marcescens. It also happens to cause disease in human beings, notably hospital infections. But the scientists couldn't prove cause and effect.

SUTHERLAND: In 2002, we could only speculate that human waste was the source of the pathogen because the pathogen is also found in the guts of other animals.

HARRIS: Like deer on the Florida Keys, so Sutherland and some colleagues exposed the coral in the laboratory to bacteria extracted from sewage and they report in the journal PLoS ONE, the coral got the pox within days.

SUTHERLAND: So that gave us definitive evidence that white pox disease is caused by a pathogen found in human sewage.

JAMES PORTER: This is almost the man-bites-dog story. This is exactly the opposite from the way it usually is.

HARRIS: James Porter of the University of Georgia also worked on the research and he says the bacteria overcame all sorts of hurdles to make this leap.

PORTER: This is a very rare and unusual evolutionary triple jump. It went from humans to the lower invertebrates, coral. It went from the terrestrial environment where we live to the marine environment and then it went from the anaerobic conditions of our stomach to the fully oxygenated conditions on the reef.

HARRIS: Jay Gewin, Utilities Manager in the city of Key West, says residents there voted to upgrade their leaky sewer system, not to save coral, per se, but to get rid of health warnings that were keeping the tourists away.

JAY GEWIN: In the early 2000s when this was such a problem, every single beach in the city of Key West would have an advisory.

HARRIS: Those health warnings on the beach are now rare, he says, thanks to a sophisticated new waste water system that cost the city more than $70 million.

GEWIN: The waste water is treated to the highest level in the state of Florida and then it goes into a deep injection well where the treated final water product is sent down thousands of feet into the ground.

HARRIS: Eventually, it may seep back into the ocean, but he says, by then, it's clean. The biologists say that since the new system was installed, elkhorn corals have stopped further die-offs around Key West. And Kathryn Sutherland says other towns along the Keys are now in the process of cleaning up their act, too, which is a helpful step.

SUTHERLAND: But this is a problem Caribbean-wide and there's a widespread lack of waste water treatment in the wider Caribbean region.

HARRIS: Richard Harris, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

MELISSA BLOCK, Host:

You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.