For Italy's Gay Rights Advocates, It's 1 Step Forward, 2 Steps Back

Oct 13, 2014
Originally published on October 13, 2014 8:19 pm

Ancient Rome may have been open to all sorts of sexual mores, but modern Italy is less so. The country lags far behind its European Union partners in guaranteeing equal rights for homosexuals.

Gay couples have no legal recognition or adoption rights in Italy, and a bill presented last year outlawing discrimination on the grounds of homophobia has been bogged down in parliament by right-wing opposition.

The legislation now faces opposition from a new conservative Catholic movement. They call themselves the Standing Sentinels, and they claim that the bill violates freedom of speech.

The group first appeared in public last spring, including at a vigil in Rome where a man on a loudspeaker welcomed a crowd of a few hundred people. He instructed them to stand about 2 yards from each other as they read books of their choosing in absolute silence.

It's their way of protesting against a bill that would make homophobia a crime punishable by law.

Standing Sentinels spokesman Pietro Invernizzi, a financial broker by profession, says, "In Italy, there is no homophobia emergency."

Like many of his fellow members, he opposes what he calls gender ideology that he says is undermining the traditional family. Most of all, he believes the anti-homophobia bill in the Italian parliament undermines freedom of speech.

"If tomorrow I would express myself publicly, 'In my opinion, a boy has the right to have a mother and a father,' or saying that, 'In my opinion, the marriage is only between a man and a woman,' I would end up in jail," says Invernizzi.

But this alarmist position is not gaining ground.

At the Silent Sentinel vigil, four young men and a woman, wearing small pink triangles reminiscent of those imposed on homosexuals in Nazi concentration camps, stood nearby, watching the silent demonstrators.

Amedeo Pagliaroli, 26, dismissed the demonstrators' claims. "They speak about gender ideology. It is not ideology, it's just a theory," Pagliaroli says. "It's just possibility of choosing how to be a man and how to be a woman. These strict and rigid forms are like cages. It doesn't help anyone."

Italy's first gay pride parade took place in Rome in 1994, and some 10,000 people attended. At this year's parade, held in June, the turnout was estimated at 100,000.

Polls show that Italians today are much more in favor of equal rights for LGBT people than they were 20 years ago.

Andrea Maccarrone, spokesman for this year's pride parade, says greater visibility has its costs. "When you are more visible, you are a target. Of course there is a backlash of Catholic conservatives who want to fight our progress."

Some religious groups have been increasingly vocal in protesting recent initiatives by several mayors to officially register same-sex marriages performed abroad, as well as a court ruling in August that approved stepchild adoption by a lesbian couple.

At the same time, the issue of homophobia has been in the spotlight with a series of suicides of gay teenagers who had been bullied in school.

"Being an LGBT person in Italy is very, very difficult," says Ivan Scalfarotto, undersecretary for constitutional reform and sponsor of the anti-homophobia bill languishing in parliament.

Scalfarotto rejects the charge that the bill would endanger freedom of expression, saying it extends existing anti-discrimination legislation to gays, lesbians and transgender people.

He had to overcome right-wing opposition himself to become the first openly gay person in an Italian government. He says, for example, that "in Italy it is completely acceptable to say homophobic jokes."

He pins the blame on an absence of the notion of political correctness in Italian culture. "So there would be no one standing up and saying, 'Guys, in my home, or in this office or workplace, this banter is not acceptable.' So it [becomes] acceptable."

But Scalfarotto believes in the power of legislation to make cultural changes.

"There are facts, there are young guys committing suicides, there are people who are beaten up, gay bashing," he says. "The issue is mostly about how we grow the country into a civilized, inclusive, respectful place for everyone, including LBGT people."

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

Italy lags behind the United States and its EU partners in equal rights for homosexuals. Gay couples have no legal recognition or adoption rights. A bill that would outlaw discrimination on the grounds of homophobia has been bogged down in Parliament by right-wing opposition, and a new conservative Catholic movement claims that the legislation violates freedom of speech. NPR's Sylvia Poggioli reports.

SYLVIA POGGIOLI, BYLINE: They call themselves the Standing Sentinels.

(SOUNDBITE OF CROWD)

POGGIOLI: They first appeared in public last spring, including this - a vigil in Rome.

(SOUNDBITE OF SPEECH)

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Speaking Italian).

POGGIOLI: A man welcomes a crowd of a few hundred people and tells them to stand about two yards from each other as they read books of their choosing in absolute silence. It's their way of protesting against a bill that would make homophobia a crime punishable by law.

PIETRO INVERNIZZI: In Italy, there is not homophobia emergency.

POGGIOLI: Pietro Invernizzi, a financial broker, is spokesman for the Standing Sentinels. Like many of its members, he opposes what he calls gender ideology that he says is undermining the traditional family. Most of all, he believes the anti-homophobia bill in the Italian parliament undermines freedom of speech.

INVERNIZZI: If tomorrow, I would express myself publicly, in my opinion, a boy has the right to have a mother and a father or same dad - in my opinion, the marriage is only between a man and a woman - I would end up in jail.

POGGIOLI: But this alarmist position is not gaining ground. Standing nearby, four young men and a woman watch the silent demonstrators. They're wearing small pink triangles, reminiscent of those imposed on homosexuals in Nazi concentration camps. Amedeo Pagliaroli is 26 years old.

AMEDEO PAGLIOROLI: They speak about gender ideology. It's not ideology. It's just a theory. It's just a possibility of choosing how to be a man and how to be women. These strict and rigid forms are like cages. It doesn't help anyone.

POGGIOLI: Italy's first gay pride parade took place in Rome in 1994, and some 10,000 people attended. This year, the turnout was estimated at 100,000. Polls show that Italians today are much more in favor of equal rights for LGBT people than they were 20 years ago.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

POGGIOLI: Andrea Maccarrone, a spokesman for this year's gay pride parade, says greater visibility has its cost.

ANDREA MACCARRONE: So when you are more visible, you are a target. Of course, there is a backlash of Catholic conservatives - the ones who fight our progress.

POGGIOLI: At the same time, the issue of homophobia has been in the spotlight, with a series of suicides of gay teenagers who had been bullied in school.

IVAN SCALFAROTTO: Being an LGBT person in Italy is very, very difficult.

POGGIOLI: Even Ivan Scalfarotto is undersecretary for constitutional reform and sponsor of the anti-homophobia bill languishing in Parliament. He rejects the charge that the bill would endanger freedom of expression, saying, it extends existing anti-discrimination legislation to gays, lesbians and transgender people. He himself had to overcome right-wing opposition to become the first openly gay person in an Italian government.

SCALFAROTTO: In Italy, it is completely acceptable to say homophobic jokes.

POGGIOLI: He pins the blame on the absence of the notion of political correctness in Italian culture.

SCALFAROTTO: So there would be no one standing up and saying, guys, in my home or in this office - in this workplace, these banters are not acceptable, so it is acceptable.

POGGIOLI: Scalfarotto believes in the power of legislation to make cultural changes.

SCALFAROTTO: There are facts - young guys committing suicide. There are people who are beaten up - gay-bashing. The issue is mostly about how we grow the country into a civilized, inclusive, respectful place for everyone, including LGBT people.

POGGIOLI: Sylvia Poggioli, NPR News, Rome.

SIEGEL: At the Vatican today, some 200 bishops who were meeting to discuss family issues released a report saying, gays have gifts to offer. The statement sounded a conciliatory note. Traditional church teaching holds that homosexuality is intrinsically disordered. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.