War Studies Suggest A Concussion Leaves The Brain Vulnerable To PTSD

Sep 26, 2016
Originally published on September 26, 2016 5:11 pm

There's growing evidence that a physical injury to the brain can make people susceptible to post-traumatic stress disorder.

Studies of troops who deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan have found that service members who have suffered a concussion or mild traumatic brain injury are far more likely to develop PTSD, a condition that can cause flashbacks, nightmares and severe anxiety for years after a traumatic event.

And research on both people and animals suggests the reason is that a brain injury can disrupt circuits that normally dampen the response to a frightening event. The result is like "driving a car and the brake's not fully functioning," says Mingxiong Huang, a biomedical physicist at the University of California, San Diego.

Scientists have suspected a link between traumatic brain injury (TBI) and PTSD for many years. But the evidence was murky until researchers began studying troops returning from Iraq and Afghanistan.

What they found was a lot of service members like Charles Mayer, an Army sniper from San Diego who developed PTSD after finishing a deployment in Iraq.

In 2010, Mayer was on patrol in an Army Humvee near Baghdad when a roadside bomb went off. "I was unconscious for several minutes," he says. So he found out what happened from the people who dragged him out.

The blast fractured Mayer's spine. It also affected his memory and thinking. That became painfully clear when Mayer got out of the Army in 2012.

"Two weeks later, I started school," he says. "And a simple math equation like 120 times 7, where I previously would do that in my head very easily, I all of a sudden couldn't do that."

And Mayer had a bigger problem. His time in Iraq had left him with an uncontrollable fear of improvised explosive devices, or IEDs.

"When I would walk down the street, I would walk away from trash piles because that's often how they would hide IEDs," he says. "I stayed away from large crowds."

Mayer's fear was not only disturbing, it was disabling. "I would get severe panic attacks to the point where I would have to go to the hospital," he says. "I would feel like I'm actually having a heart attack."

Eventually, Mayer went to a Veterans Affairs hospital for help. An exam confirmed that he had PTSD.

The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have produced thousands of Charles Mayers. First they got a concussion from a bomb blast. Then they got PTSD.

"We had people who were looking very miserable when they came back," says Dewleen Baker, a psychiatrist at UCSD and the VA San Diego Healthcare System.

Baker kept asking herself: Was the PTSD just from the emotional trauma of combat? Or did a concussion alter the brain in a way that amplified fear and anxiety?

"I could easily diagnose the PTSD," she says. "But I found it very, very difficult to tease apart the contribution of traumatic brain injury."

So Baker and a team of researchers began studying more than 1,600 Marine and Navy service members from Camp Pendleton, in San Diego County, Calif. The service members had been assessed before deploying to Iraq or Afghanistan, and then again three months after returning.

"At one point we got this battalion that went to Helmand province in Afghanistan, and literally 50 percent of them were complaining of blast exposures and symptoms," Baker says. "I got concerned."

Baker had reason to worry. The study found that troops who experienced a traumatic brain injury were twice as likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder.

But why? There was no easy way to answer that question in people. But several years ago some answers began to emerge from animal studies.

In one experiment, a team of scientists at the University of California, Los Angeles compared healthy rats with rats that had experienced a traumatic brain injury. All of the rats received a type of behavioral conditioning known to induce fear.

They found that fear response learned by the animals that had experienced a TBI was much greater than it normally would be, says Michael Fanselow, a psychology professor at UCLA and an author of the study.

Next, the team looked at cells in the amygdala, a part of the brain that takes sensory information and decides whether to be afraid. They found changes that would amplify the animal's response to a frightening experience.

"And we think that that's the way TBI has of increasing your susceptibility to post-traumatic stress," Fanselow says.

If brain injuries really do change the brain's fear circuitry, there should be some way to detect that change in people, says Baker.

So Baker teamed up with her colleague Mingxiong Huang, the biomedical physicist. Huang has been using a technology that measures electrical activity in the brain. It's called magnetoencephalography,or MEG.

Huang and a team of researchers used MEG to scan the brains of 84 people who had experienced a brain injury. Some of the participants were service members, some were civilians.

Those scans found abnormal signals coming from the brains of people who'd had a concussion. And the location of those abnormal signals suggested that there was too much activity going on in the amygdala and not enough in an area that normally tempers emotional reactions.

The result is a brain that is "like a car with no brake," Huang says.

To learn more about the brain circuitry involved in both TBI and PTSD, Dewleen Baker is expanding her earlier study of Marines. She plans to scan the brains of about 200 combat veterans, including some with both TBI and PTSD.

And Baker will have help from a researcher with a personal stake in the project: Charles Mayer, the former soldier whose college career was interrupted by PTSD.

After getting treatment, Mayer was able to finish his undergraduate degree in December. Then Mayer, who is now 30, started looking for a job that would let him study the problems that had affected his own brain.

"I looked up the psychiatrists that were doing research that I really cared about, and Dr. Baker was definitely up there," he says. And Baker hired him.

Their research will focus on veterans. But the findings could also help identify civilians who've suffered a brain injury that could make them vulnerable to PTSD.

Copyright 2016 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

And in Your Health this morning, we're learning about the link between concussions and post-traumatic stress disorder. For a while now, researchers have suspected that even a mild brain injury can make a person more vulnerable to PTSD. And the link became much clearer when scientists began studying troops returning from Iraq and Afghanistan. Here's NPR's Jon Hamilton.

JON HAMILTON, BYLINE: Scientists who study PTSD have been learning a lot from people like Charles Mayer. In 2010, Mayer was on patrol in an Army Humvee near Baghdad. Then a roadside bomb went off.

CHARLES MAYER: I was unconscious, you know, for several minutes. So I know the story from the people that, you know, that dragged me out, my buddies.

HAMILTON: The blast fractured a bone in Mayer's spine. It also affected his memory.

MAYER: But I didn't really realize the effects that it would cause, like, cognitively, so to speak.

HAMILTON: Mayer's thinking was impaired. That became painfully clear when he got out of the Army in 2012.

MAYER: Two weeks later, I started school. And a simple math equation, like 120 times seven, where I previously would do that in my head very easily, I all of a sudden couldn't do that.

HAMILTON: And Mayer had a bigger problem. His time in Iraq had left him with an uncontrollable fear of improvised explosive devices, or IEDs.

MAYER: When I would walk down the street, I would walk away from trash piles 'cause that's often how they would hide IEDs. I stayed away from large crowds.

HAMILTON: Eventually, Mayer went to the VA for help. An exam confirmed that he had PTSD. And Mayer says it was bad.

MAYER: I would get severe panic attacks - and to the point, you know, so severe where I would be - have to go to the hospital, you know, 'cause I would feel like I'm actually having a heart attack.

HAMILTON: The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan produced thousands of Charles Mayers. First they got a concussion. Then they got PTSD. And Dewleen Baker has seen many of these veterans. She's a psychiatrist at the University of California, San Diego, who also runs a PTSD clinic at the local VA Medical Center. Baker remembers a time early in the wars when she began seeing more and more returning troops with symptoms of both PTSD and brain injury.

DEWLEEN BAKER: We had people who were looking very miserable when they came back and reporting a blast injury and some difficulty thinking.

HAMILTON: Baker kept asking herself, was the PTSD just from the emotional trauma of combat, or did a concussion alter the brain in a way that amplified fear and anxiety?

BAKER: I could easily diagnose the PTSD. But I found it very, very difficult to tease apart the contribution of traumatic brain injury, what was going on with their cognition.

HAMILTON: So Baker and a team of researchers began studying more than 1,600 Marines from Camp Pendleton. The Marines had been assessed before deploying to Iraq or Afghanistan and then again three months after returning.

BAKER: At one point, we got this battalion that went to Helmand Province in Afghanistan. And literally 50 percent of them were complaining of blast exposures and symptoms, and I got concerned.

HAMILTON: Baker had reason to worry. The study found that Marines who experienced a traumatic brain injury, or TBI, were much more likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder.

BAKER: TBI doubled the rate of PTSD in some cases.

HAMILTON: But why? There was no easy way to answer that question in people. But a team of scientists at the University of California, Los Angeles, had been studying rats. Michael Fanselow says the team focused on the amygdala, an area of the brain that processes information coming from the senses.

MICHAEL FANSELOW: The amygdala takes the sensory information and decides, should I learn to be afraid? Should I give a fear response? What should I do in this situation?

HAMILTON: Fanselow did an experiment. It compared healthy rats with rats that had experienced a traumatic brain injury. He says all of the rats received a type of behavioral conditioning known to induce fear.

FANSELOW: What happened in the animals that experienced a TBI is that this fear response that they learned during the situation was exaggerated. It was much greater than it normally would be.

HAMILTON: And Fanselow says the brain injury changed more than the rats' behavior. There were obvious changes in the amygdala.

FANSELOW: So it seemed like the amygdala was geared to really be able to strongly learn new fear information. And we think that that's the way TBI has of increasing your susceptibility to post-traumatic stress.

HAMILTON: Back at UC, San Diego, psychiatrist Dewleen Baker had come to a conclusion. If brain injuries really do change the brain's fear circuitry, there should be some way to detect that change in people. So she teamed up with Mingxiong Huang, a biomedical physicist in the radiology department. Huang had been using a technology that measures electrical activity in the brain. It's called magnetoencephalography, or MEG for short.

MINGXIONG HUANG: And you come in over here.

HAMILTON: OK.

Huang shows me the room where his team used MEG to scan the brains of 84 people. Some were service members. Some were civilians. But they'd all experienced a brain injury. Huang points to a chair beneath a helmet-like hood designed to detect brain signals. He says what the scans from this device revealed was intriguing. People with brain injuries often have too much activity in the amygdala and not enough in an area that moderate's emotional reactions. Huang says these people appear to have brains that are likely to overreact when something frightening happens.

HUANG: Just like when you're driving a car, there's a brake. And you have an engine, but you need a brake. But in the case of PTSD and driving a car, the brake's not fully functioning.

HAMILTON: Now Dewleen Baker is getting ready to expand her study of Marines. She wants to scan the brains of about 200 combat veterans, including some with both TBI and PTSD. Baker will have help on this project from Charles Mayer, the former soldier whose college career was interrupted by PTSD. After getting treatment, Mayer was able to finish his undergraduate degree.

MAYER: I actually graduated early (laughter), believe it or not.

HAMILTON: That was in December. Then Mayer started looking for a job. He wanted something that would let him study the problems that had affected his own brain.

MAYER: I looked up the psychiatrists that were doing research that I really cared about, and Dr. Baker was definitely up there.

HAMILTON: Baker hired him. Their research will focus on veterans, but the findings could also help identify civilians who suffered a brain injury that makes them vulnerable to PTSD. Jon Hamilton, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.