Residents Worry Urban Drilling Will Turn Downtowns Into Oil Towns

Sep 3, 2014
Originally published on September 4, 2014 3:18 pm

Dawn Gioia lives just two blocks away from City Hall in Brighton, Colo., just north of Denver. She never expected to receive a thick envelope from Mid-Continent Energy in the mail, proposing she sell mineral rights for oil and gas drilling.

At first, she thought it was a scam.

"One of these forms asks you for all your tax information and Social Security numbers, so that was something that sort of caught me off guard," she says.

The packet also included a lease for her mineral rights. The terms include a $1,200 signing bonus for every acre owned, and 18 percent after that.

As she read it over, Gioia realized, she says, "They actually think they want to drill here, under our property."

The energy extraction method known as fracking is moving into midsize cities — and not just on the fringes. Drilling for oil and gas isn't new in rural or even suburban areas, but as extraction companies move into cities, it's raising a new set of concerns.

Gioia says her neighbors were also surprised to receive similar offers from Mid-Continent Energy — including her mother-in-law, who owns a townhome a few miles away.

They didn't quite know what to make of the letters. "I don't know — do they own the land?" Gioia says. Her mother-in-law was "really confused," she says, and Gioia was, too.

Gioia called the energy company to learn more. The man she reached, she says, reminded her of a sleazy car salesman. "He was pretty much just like, 'Sign it, sign it, sign it.' "

His pushy tone inspired her to call a lawyer and organize a neighborhood meeting.

"There's all kinds of questions that come up, of how does this work? Is there going to be like, trucks driving through our neighborhood every day? What happens to the property values? I did have one neighbor say, 'Should I sell before they start this?' "

With her small plot, Gioia says, she doesn't think she'd make much money by leasing. In the best-case scenario, she says, the profits could be about $200 a month.

Mid-Continent Energy declined to be interviewed for this story, saying only that it would be premature to discuss development plans before reaching an agreement with a mineral owner.

Residents in the nearby city of Greeley, with a population of about 100,000, are fighting proposals to expand drilling there. Sara Barwinski lives about 750 feet from an active drill pad.

"That site is also adjacent to a high school, 411 feet from a track-and-field [location] in a high-density residential area," Barwinski says.

She then clenches her hands as she describes a proposal to drill multiple wells near an elementary school. "Why should we be preparing evacuation plans for a kindergartner?"

Barwinski worries about an accident in a dense urban core. It would be difficult to evacuate hospital patients or retirement home residents, she says.

But Barbara Kirkmeyer, a local county commissioner, argues that state regulations are strong enough to prevent accidents. Plus, she says, drilling is good for the economy.

"The businesses that are in town all seem to be booming. I mean, if you walk along Main Street here, it's just bustling."

Kirkmeyer also says the dollars extend beyond city limits. "We're all going to figure out how we're going to coexist, because it's extremely important to our economy. And it's not just our economy here in Weld County — it's our economy in the state of Colorado."

Urban drilling is also happening in midsize cities in other parts of the country, like North Texas and Southern California. Drilling is also up in larger cities like Los Angeles. The majority of production there, however, is not close to downtown.

Back in Brighton, Dawn Gioia and her husband are weighing the pros and cons of signing a lease. She predicts her household will probably be the last on her block to decide whether to sign over its mineral rights.

She's not against fracking; she says she recognizes the importance of oil and gas. But she worries about potential spills, because Brighton's municipal water comes from shallow aquifers.

Mostly, she's concerned about the future.

"I don't want to become an oil town. When the oil leaves or when it dries up, what will happen to Brighton when it's gone?" she says. "I know they say, 'Hey, it's good for the economy. You're going to bring all these workers, and everyone's going to get work.' But when it's dried up, then what happens?"

Copyright 2014 Colorado Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.cpr.org.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

When we hear about places where fracking is happening, they're usually rural. But hydraulic fracturing is moving into some cities and not just around the fringes - right downtown. In urban areas, fracking is raising a new set of concerns. Colorado Public Radio's Lesley McClurg has this story about a about a proposal to drill right underneath one woman's downtown home.

LESLEY MCCLURG, BYLINE: Dawn Gioia is a busy stay-at-home mom. On her back porch, her 1-year-old son pounds a mini keyboard. Her 7-year-old daughter plays dress-up.

DAWN GIOIA: Well, do you guys want to get your stuff ready for the pool? Will you go get your suit? Do you know where your brother's swimsuit is?

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD: I saw it on the counter yesterday.

MCCLURG: Frequently, the family spends summer days at the nearby city waterpark. They live on a corner lot two blocks away from City Hall in Brighton. It's just north of Denver.

GIOIA: Do me a favor - go downstairs, look and see if you can find your green bikini.

MCCLURG: As urban residents, Gioia never expected to receive a thick envelope from Mid-Con Energy. At first she thought it was a scam.

GIOIA: You can see that one of these forms asks you for all your tax information and Social Security numbers. So that was something that sort of caught me off guard.

MCCLURG: The packet also included a lease for her mineral rights. The terms are a $1,200 signing bonus for every acre owned and 18 percent after that.

GIOIA: So I read it over and I was like, they actually think they want to drill here, under our property.

MCCLURG: She says her neighbors were also surprised to see to receive similar offers - like her mother-in-law, who owns a townhome a few miles away.

GIOIA: So I don't know - do they own the land? She's really confused.

MCCLURG: To find the answers, Gioia called the energy company. She says the man she reached reminded her of a sleazy car salesman.

GIOIA: He was pretty much just like, sign it, sign it, sign it.

MCCLURG: His pushy tone inspired her to call a lawyer and organize a neighborhood meeting.

GIOIA: There's all kinds of questions that come up of how does this work? Is there going to be like, trucks driving through our neighborhood every day? What happens to the property values? I did have one neighbor say, should I sell before they start this (laughter)?

MCCLURG: Is the money or the profits a potential big draw?

GIOIA: No. I live on a small plot. Like, we live in a neighborhood.

MCCLURG: She says in the best case scenario, the profits could be about $200 a month. Mid-Con Energy declined to be interviewed for this story, saying only, that it would be premature to discuss development plans before reaching an agreement with a mineral owner. Residents of the nearby city of Greeley - at about 100,000 people - are fighting proposals to expand drilling there. Sara Barwinski lives about 750 feet from an active drill pad.

SARA BARWINSKI: And that site is also adjacent to a high school - 411 feet from a track and field, in a high-destiny residential area.

MCCLURG: She clenches her hands as she describes a proposal to drill multiple wells near in elementary school.

BARWINSKI: Why should we be preparing evacuation plans for a kindergartner?

MCCLURG: Barwinski worries about an accident in a dense urban core. She stresses that it would be difficult to evacuate hospital patients or retirement home residents. But Barbara Kirkmeyer, a county commissioner in the area, argues that state regulations are strong enough to prevent accidents. Plus, she says, drilling is good for the economy.

BARBARA KIRKMEYER: The businesses that are in town all seem to be booming. I mean, if you walk along Main Street here, it's just bustling.

MCCLURG: Kirkmeyer also says the dollars extend beyond city limits.

KIRKMEYER: We're all going to figure how we're going to coexist because it's extremely important to our economy. And it's not just our economy here in Weld County; it's our economy in the state of Colorado.

MCCLURG: Urban drilling is also happening in midsized cities in other parts of the country, like North Texas and Southern California. And drilling is up in larger cities like Los Angeles. However, the majority of production there is not close to downtown.

Back at Gioia's house in Brighton, Colorado, she and her husband are weighing the pros and cons of signing a lease. She says she recognizes the importance of oil and gas, but she worries about potential spills because Brighton's municipal water comes from shallow aquifers. Mostly, she's concerned about the future.

GIOIA: I don't want to become an oil town. When the oil leaves or when it dries up, what will happen to Brighton when it's gone? Because they say, hey, it's good for the economy; you're going to bring all these workers and everyone's going to get work. But when it's dried up, then what happens?

MCCLURG: Gioia predicts she'll probably be the last one on her block to decide whether to sign over her mineral rights.

For NPR News, I'm Lesley McClurg in Denver. [POST-BROADCAST CORRECTION: incorrectly says that Brighton, Colo., residents were approached by Mid-Con Energy regarding mineral rights. They were actually approached by Mid-Continent Energy, which is an unaffiliated entity.] Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.